e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil Auburn Dual-Ended Precision Tip and Spoolie Smudge-Resistant Long-Lasting Formula

4.9★★★★★★★★★★9 reviews

• 5 ★8
• 4 ★1
• 3 ★0
• 2 ★0
• 1 ★0

Used this product?Your review helps other shoppers choose.Write a review

Write a reviewe.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil Auburn Dual-Ended Precision Tip and Spoolie Smudge-Resistant Long-Lasting Formula

Top reviews first: highest rated, with photos first

• AAleesha S.23 Jul 2026
  5 ★

  Great eyebrow pencil & the one i would pick if I had no budget limits- still!

  I have always ordered the regular version of this- NON waterproof for years & years on end. This one is not in my opinion completely actually "waterproofed" but more very water resistant & despite extreme temperatures- stays put all day long.It didn't stay on in the pool.It works like a mechanical pencil & the other end has a spoolie.I have a quick routine & even if I had no budget I would still pick this pencil regardless. The dark brown looks great with very deep black dyed dark hair like i have.

  Read moreShow less
• SSumit18 Jul 2026
  5 ★

  Best blond pencil I've tried.

  I never write reviews, I mean NEVER. But, I had to write about this brow pencil. First of all, the blond is actually blond, not orange, or grey, or green, like some of the other brow pencils I've gotten. I have golden blond hair, and it's slightly darker than my hair, so it looks very natural. Secondly, it is definitely sweatproof, and it does stay on in water. If you rub your brows when they're wet, like I accidentally did, it'll rub off a little bit. But otherwise, it's the most waterproof brow pencil I've tried. It lasts all day too, and it doesn't fade. For the low price, it is definitely worth it.

  Read moreShow less
• AArnav3 Jul 2026
  5 ★

  My favorite brow pencil, natural and effortless

  I absolutely love this pencil in Taupe. The color gives the most natural finish and works beautifully across a range of hair colors, from blonde to light and medium brown. It blends seamlessly and never looks overdone when applied with a light hand.The spoolie on the other end is genuinely useful. I use it to brush and shape the brows before and during application, which helps guide the hairs into place and creates a much more polished result.The creamy texture glides on smoothly with minimal effort and distributes evenly without any clumping. The pigment is rich enough to fill sparse areas but the key is not to press too hard, otherwise it is easy to overdo it. A light touch gives the most natural look.The staying power is impressive. Throughout the day the color holds up well even if you accidentally touch your brows. Only if you deliberately rub them will the color come off. My brows look the same in the evening as they did in the morning.I have gone through many of these pencils and the quality and price are consistently excellent. My only wish is that e.l.f. would release the same formula in a wooden pencil that you sharpen, since the retractable format tends to run out faster. That said, it will not stop me from repurchasing.Also worth mentioning, e.l.f. is vegan and cruelty-free, which is always a welcome bonus.

  Read moreShow less
• VVatsal S.30 Jun 2026
  5 ★

  Perfect Pencil

  I have been using the e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil for quite some time now, and it continues to be one of my favorite beauty products. The first thing I love about this eyebrow pencil is how smoothly it glides on. The formula is soft enough to apply easily without tugging at the skin, yet it provides excellent control for creating natural-looking brows.One of the biggest advantages of this product is that it is truly waterproof. Throughout the day, my eyebrows stay in place without smudging, fading, or wearing off, even in humid weather or during long days. This gives me confidence that my brows will continue to look great from morning until night.I also really like the color selection. The shade I use matches my brows very well and helps create a natural, polished look without appearing too dark or harsh. The pencil makes it easy to fill in sparse areas and define the shape of my brows for a clean, finished appearance.Another feature I appreciate is the dual-ended design. The spoolie brush helps blend the product evenly and keeps my brows looking soft and natural. It is convenient to have both tools in one product, making application quick and easy.The quality of this eyebrow pencil is excellent, especially for the affordable price. I have tried other eyebrow products over the years, but I always find myself coming back to this one because it consistently delivers great results. It is reliable, long-lasting, easy to use, and provides beautiful-looking brows every time.Overall, I highly recommend the e.l.f. Instant Lift Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil to anyone looking for an affordable, effective, and long-lasting eyebrow product. I have always used this product, and I will probably continue to use it for years to come because it works wonderfully and never disappoints.

  Read moreShow less